The Assassin Brotherhood had let their guard down after Achilles' untimely death when the Templars attacked. Although the Homestead residents are spared, the Assassins are rounded up to be tried and executed. They grudgingly accept their fate, even when Haytham offers to spare them in exchange that they switch allegiances in order to replace the Templar militant forces that have been lost in the war with the Assassins.

While imprisoned, the recruits are brutally beaten in front of Connor who is forced to watch. Picture Connor being restrained tightly in a chair while being forced to watch one of his recruits after another being beaten by Templar mercenaries with Lee and Hickey present and accusing Connor of being a failure as a mentor to allow his apprentices suffer. He's brought before the Grand Master again, and begs for his friends to spared. Haytham agrees to let them live, only if Connor becomes his slave.

When Connor commits himself to being a slave, he has no idea what is in store for him as he's brought to Haytham's bedroom: bound, blindfolded, and gagged. Imagine Haytham has wanted to fuck and discipline his unruly son for sometime; and over the course of a few weeks, has his way with Connor and fulfilling every dark fantasy he's ever had for the Assassin. At first he hates his new position and his father, but as time passes, Connor begins to enjoy being a slave.